200710261439
26-Oct-07
right wing or left wing? i liked this post from my brother, particularly the poster. the comments caused me to take a look into the definitions and ideas of “winged” politics as told by wikipedia. as a conservative, i didn’t really like what i read.
in general the article does a good job comparing and contrasting the two sides and then summarizing the history and present condition of the two view-points. however there is one particular issue that i would like to address and critique.
of all the terminology of the article (written and edited by many, many people), the most unsettling and uneven comparison of the two ideologies is this: right-wingers are “conservativism” while left-wingers are “innovation“. i cringe just typing it.
my first reaction simply is that the words are not equal. an exaggerated example might be that when comparing apples to oranges one says, “the skin of an orange is orange” and then, “the skin of an apple is tasty“. even in clicking through to the provided links, the two articles themselves are not even comparable. the article for innovation is a thorough definition of the word with an array of examples. please note there are no references in this article to the left-wing. on the other hand the article for conservatism is appropriately an article on the definition, spectrum, and ideology of the political theory of conservatism.
why in the world would the left-wing get the dubious title of innovative? i have no idea. if someone could name more than 5 things that the left-wing has innovated in the government in the past 5 years, they would be hard-pressed to do so.
liberalism to me would be a more equivalent term to apply in this case. however when reading the article, it is apparent that it is only talking about global liberalism tendencies and certainly not american liberalism. i need only to quote this line from the second paragraph of the article: “Broadly speaking, liberalism emphasizes individual rights and equality of opportunity.” HAHAHAHAHAHA, maybe this is an accurate definition worldwide, but it certainly doesn’t describe the mommy-state, socialist agenda of the american-left. so by my own reasoning, i have yet to find a term that appropriately compares the american right to the american left in terms of polictical ideology. not to mention the fact the liberalism described in the article directly contradicts the left wing ideas presented in the right-left wing article. i must find a more accurate term for comparison.
i thusly would change “innovation” to “social liberalism” and not feel bad about it at all. if i were feeling saucy, i would just change it to socialism. but i discourage wiki-vandalism.